|
Home / Offices & Ministries / Parish Life & Services / RCIA / Outline of major differences between Catholic and other major faith traditions
Outline of major differences between Catholic and other major faith traditions
| Lutherans |
|
Major differences:
- Authority in the Church
- The way a person is saved
- Eucharist...the Presence of Jesus is added to the Bread and Wine during the celebration but does not remain after the celebration is complete
- Have some understanding of Confession, but do not consider it sacramental
- The Bible alone is the source of doctrine
- Faith in Christ is the only way to obtain personal salvation
- Reject prayer to Mary and saints as well use of icons and images
- Reject the notion of Purgatory, but have recently included prayers for the dead in their prayerbooks (ELCA)
- Their ministers may marry
- Women can be ordained (in ECLA)
- Divorce is tragic but sometimes the best option
- Accept remarriage
They believe in:
- Apostles' Creed, Nicene Creed, Athanasian Creed, Augsburg confession, Formula of Concord
- Trinity
- Christ is truly human and truly divine
|
There are two main branches of Lutheranism in the U.S.:
- Evangelical Lutheran Church in America [ECLA]
- Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod [LCMS] - tends to be more fundamentalist
Catechesis required:
- Ecclesiology including:
- justification by faith and good works
- church as Body of Christ
- church as community
- church is one, holy, catholic and apostolic
- hierarchical structure of the Church ... and authority in the Church
- infallibility
- Communion of Saints, Mary and the Saints
- Eucharistic theology ...our understanding of:
- Transubstantiation
- Real Presence
- Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament
- Holy Orders and Marriage
Also necessary for them to become part of the community and to participate with the community in its missionary activities.
|
Back to top
| Baptists |
|
Major differences:
- Justification by faith alone
- Jesus Christ is not really present in the Eucharist
- Reject transubstantiation and real presence
Other differences:
- Operate on a Congregationalist Governance system in which every local church has sutonomy - therefore there are differences from one congregation to another
- Officers are the elders or bishops and the deacons who are elected by members of the congregation
- Reject infant baptism - only those become members who make a profession of faith
- Baptism by immersion is the only mode accepted
- No creeds
- "Priesthood of all believers"...that every Christian has direct access to God and the truths found in the Bible without help
- Only two ordinances {sacraments): Baptism and the Lord's Supper...both are mere symbols
- Tend to be fundamentalist (especially Southern Baptists)
- Ministers may marry
- In some congregations women may be ordained
Baptists believe in:
- The divinity of Jesus and the Holy Spirit
- The Trinity
- Literal Second Coming of Christ
Their worship services consist of the proclamation of the Word of God through the weekly sermon. |
Catechesis required:
- Ecclesiology including:
- justification by faith and good works
- Scripture, Church tradition and reason form
- the foundation of our faith and practice
- church as Body of Christ
- church as community
- church is one, holy, catholic and apostolic
- hierarchical structure of the Church ... and authority in the Church
- infallibility
- Communion of Saints, Mary and the Saints, prayers for the dead
- Eucharistic theology ...our understanding of
- Transubstantiation
- Real Presence
- Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament
- Sacramental theology and our understanding of Holy Orders and Marriage, Infant baptism
- Introduction into liturgical worship
- Deutero-canonical Books of the Bible
Also necessary for them to become part of the community and to participate with the community in its missionary activities.
|
Back to top
| Episcopalian/Anglican |
|
Major differences:
- Celibacy is not required of clergy
- Permit the ordination of women*
- Eucharist is open to all baptized Christians and is offered in both bread and wine
- Democratic structure of the church
- Prayers to the saints is not common, but they are recognized and commemorated
- The diocese is the primary unit of governance
They believe in:
- Scripture as the revealed Word of God
- The historical creeds of the Church (the Apostles' Creed and the Nicene Creed) as sufficient statements of Christian belief
- The celebration of the seven sacraments with special emphasis on Baptism and Eucharist
- The use of Scripture, Church tradition, and reason in matters of belief and practice
- The apostolic ministry of bishops, priests and deacons in the life of teaching and service in the Church
- The "Branch Theory": an understanding that the Church of Christ is present in different "branches" such as the Roman, the Orthodox, the Anglican, all of whom are considered "Catholic"
- The Trinity....three persons in one God
- That Jesus Christ is fully human, and fully divine
- Salvation by faith not good works
There are different branches of Episcopalians with varying understandings of Eucharistic theology.
|
Catechesis required:
- Ecclesiology including:
- justification by faith and good works
- church as Body of Christ
- church as community
- church is one, holy, catholic and apostolic
- hierarchical structure of the universal Church and authority in the Church
- infallibility
- Communion of Saints, Mary and the Saints
- Eucharistic theology - our understanding of:
- Transubstantiation
- Real Presence
- Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament
- Eucharist as the sacrament of unity
- Holy Orders and Marriage
Also necessary for them to become part of the community and to participate with the community in its missionary activities.
* Some Episcopalians (Anglicans) do not recognize women bishops. The recent election of a woman as presiding bishop in the Episcopal Church has caused much friction. Many Episcopalians interested in becoming Catholic may be coming from a more conservative or traditional mindset.
|
Back to top
| Presbyterians |
|
Major differences:
- Holy Scriptures are the only rule of faith and conduct....stress the importance of scholarship re. Scriptures
- Only two sacraments: baptism and the Lord's Supper {Holy Communion}
- Eucharist...Jesus is spiritually present in the elements; physical elements do not change; Jesus is genuinely present there
- Justification by grace through faith
- Church is governed at all levels by a combination of clergy and laity, men and women alike
- There are no bishops but rather the office of elder...commissioned non-clergy elected by the congregation who take part in local pastoral care and decision-making at all levels
- Mary is not the mediator between man and God; she is honored as God-bearer and model for the Christian
- Deny Purgatory
- Believe in Predestination
- Women can be ordained
- Variety of positions on eschatology
They believe in:
- Apostles' Creed, Nicene Creed, Westminster Confession
- Trinity
- Christ is truly human and fully God
- Strong commitment to missionary activity
|
Catechesis required:
- Ecclesiology including:
- justification by faith and good works
- church as Body of Christ
- church as community
- church is one, holy, catholic and apostolic
- hierarchical structure of the Church ... and authority in the Church
- infallibility
- Communion of Saints, Mary and the Saints
- Eucharistic theology - our understanding of
- Transubstantiation
- Real Presence
- Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament
- Holy Orders and Marriage and other sacraments
|
Back to top
|